January 31, 2023

Reimagine Sustainability Logo

Can The Tragedy Of The Commons Be Solved With Economic Degrowth?

Change is inevitable. What should we do when a number of people cling to a system that is harmful but the norm? Economic degrowth is mocked by the corporate world and governments. Although it seems irrational to continue an economic system that is based on exploitation and destruction, there is little openness to rethink our global economies. Does a remedy exist? Imagine what a future that favours prosperity and sustainable development could look like. I have difficulty imagining a sustainable global economy. Let me introduce you to degrowth and the tragedy of the commons. Two concepts not paired before!
Written by Veronika Tietz

How often have you heard that economic degrowth is too complex, too complicated or too expensive? 

Degrowth – part of sustainable development – is not an economic recession or a sober plan to return to the dark ages. Today, I want to show you that degrowth is not a step backwards, but a better way forward. Degrowth – part of sustainable development – is not an economic recession or a sober plan to return to the dark ages.

Part of the idea of degrowth is that the needs of current generations are met without diminishing the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. Furthermore, degrowth acts as a measuring scale to create a balance between economic activities and environmental stability.

One aspect of economic sustainable development is often overlooked. It is the damage caused by historic abuse. What it means is the social and environmental damage caused in the past which is a crucial part of how we function as societies nowadays. As with carbon emissions, past, current and future regeneration need to be taken into account to achieve holistic sustainability. 

Let’s have a look at what needs to change.

Why our economies and societies need to change

For a big number of reasons, societies all over the world are urged for economic as well as societal change – in particular in affluent nations. 

The prevalent societal systems support unsustainable, exploitative and damaging behaviour which, unfortunately, is the norm. Examplaratory, the term ‘throwaway culture’ is linked to a concept that only exists in the human world: waste.

Degrowth For People And Planet

The well-being of planet and people is important

 

Waste does not occur in the natural world. Over billions of years, the natural environment developed ecosystems where waste products recirculate into the system. Consequently, it enables nature to develop prosperous and diverse life systems.

Nothing is left behind. Everything has its purpose. 

UNsustainable systems make life harder for us – Is degrowth the answer?

In the modern world, single-use and limited-lifetime items are the norm and discarded after their usefulness has been exhausted. Surely, at first glance, they seem convenient and cheap, but the real price will be paid in the future.

Numerous problems come with this type of system where waste generation is “normal”. 

Waste takes on different forms such as plastic waste, food waste, clothes waste, energy waste, water waste, chemical waste, medical waste and many others. Even carbon is a waste product because there is more in the atmosphere than can be naturally captured.

Related:

The Rs Of Sustainability: The Most Effective Way To Apply Them

The current economic model is fueling waste generation from which many industries profit. Unfortunately, we can not afford this type of system any longer. As you see, UNsustainability is the norm in almost every corner where people have a finger in the pie.

There are many more faulty systems created by humans. Waste is one of the easier to understand and valuable to visualise the underlying issues.

Economic degrowth is more needed than globally admit

Our economic systems reward people who exploit others and the environment. I do not know many people who are happy at their job. Most work to meet needs ends.

While most people live below the poverty level, others enjoy luxury lifestyles at the expense of others’ hard work or oppression.

In 1833, the British writer William Forster Lloyd framed the tragedy of the commons. The tragedy of the commons refers to the challenge of human self-interest in regard to publicly accessible resources which can easily be exploited. This TedEd Video explains the economic theory brilliantly:

What is the tragedy of the commons? – Nicholas Amendolare

Many people lack education and access to information because they live in regions where resources are scarce. Not only this, those regions are targeted by corporations that seek out places, where labour costs are low and environmental regulations are not strict enough.

It is not only about a lack of educational resources, communities are knowingly prevented from meeting their own needs. Those needs are usually pretty simple like affordable housing and food. 

We might think that poor people can learn from us. How to find an apartment or how to find a job. But the issues are in most cases systemic problems where ‘simple’ endeavours are specifically difficult for certain groups of people.

We see development as progress, but it cannot be progress when it becomes harder and harder to lead a simple life. 

There is enough money, but there are not enough resources to support a westernised lifestyle. Degrowth is an opportunity to create lifestyles that are good for societies and natural well-being – in accordance with natural and cultural laws.

What does it have to do with you?

There are two simple questions I want to ask you:

 

  1. What are your strengths?*
  2. How do you want to create a future worth looking forward to?

 

*If you are unsure about your strengths, I recommend you take this free test from the VIA Character Strengths Survey. It helps me a lot to adjust my goals according to my strengths. (I’m not benefiting monetarily from this link. I simply share this resource with you because it helped me a lot in many regards.) –> Let us know your answers in the comment section below!

The reason why I do not want to tell you what to do about the above-listed issues is that a one-size-fits-all solution does not work. Degrowth is a concept about reflecting how we want to act as societies on the only planet that enables our existence.

This is our moment to reimagine our future and create one we can look forward to.

Related:

A Sustainable 2023 Starts With You! Create A Future To Look Forward To

Sharing is Caring

Make A Meaningful Impact: Alyona From Dobrosphera

Make A Meaningful Impact is an interview series about people – like you and me – who make a difference in our world. All of us are deeply concerned with the state of the world, but we cannot solve the world’s challenges ourselves. Therefore, I created the series Make A Meaningful Impact, where I invite different people to an interview to show us what they do to make our extraordinary world a livable and enjoyable home. They found their journey and role in contributing to a better future – a future to look forward to.

5 Helpful Steps To Understand The Concept Of Systems Better

Wouldn’t it be amazing if we could work together to tackle humanity’s most pressing challenges? Interestingly enough, this is possible because natural systems show us how. Unfortunately, we got rid of a big chunk of natural systems, but this doesn’t mean that we cannot reverse it. The systems concept is an ideal approach to understanding the underlying problems we are facing AND finding the right solutions. We are an integral part of our Earth’s systems as well as any other species or resource. I can show you what it takes to understand systems better and contribute to a better world.

Sustainability Podcast: WHO’S GONNA SAVE US

The WHO’S GONNA SAVE US podcast is about the heroes who will enable the world to avert the worst impacts of a climate disaster: people like you and me. Questions about “Why do we have to do it?” are changed to “How are we going to do it?” This podcast provides you with inspirational stories from people who simply want a better future. A future where we are not threatened by the climate crisis. How they are doing it is wonderfully discovered by the host Jo Lauder and her team.

Sustainability Thinking: The World Is Ending. What Are You Taking With You?

In view of the many crises we need to overcome, it can feel quite daunting. Too many think they do not have enough of what it takes to make our world sustainable. It might be true because they think in a way that does not encourage action. Thinking differently has been frowned upon for too long. But that’s what we need: the diverse capabilities of all human brains. Sustainability thinking can become a successful pathway to deal with environmental issues, social unrest and economic collapse. A sustainable future depends on the way you imagine it. Make the most out of it!

10 Simple Reasons Why It’s Not Too Late For Sustainability

It’s not easy being a human in a world which seems to crumble around us. Finding encouraging and helpful support to tackle our world’s crisis is not easy. Many already say that we can’t achieve Sustainability anymore. What nonsense! In this article, I want to show you 10 simple reasons why we can still achieve Sustainability. Even better, it won’t be as difficult as you might think. Our world is complex, but not everything needs to be hypercomplex. Sometimes the simple things in life will bring us where we should be. Curious? You’re more than welcome to continue reading.

Understanding Acknowledgement Of Country As Non-Indigeneous

Understanding Acknowledgement of Country as a Non-Indigenous individual is essential for embracing cultural understanding and reconciliation. This practice requires overcoming challenges, such as unfamiliarity with Indigenous customs, potential misconceptions, and discomfort with discussing historical injustices. By actively engaging in education, seeking guidance from local Indigenous communities, and cultivating empathy, we can navigate these challenges and develop a deeper appreciation for the significance of Acknowledgement of Country. Embracing this practice offers an opportunity to build respectful relationships, challenge preconceptions, and contribute to a more inclusive society rooted in Indigenous wisdom and cultural understanding.

Why Systems Thinking Is So Useful To Achieve Sustainability

Systems thinking should become one of the number one approaches to solving societal challenges. It’s a problem-solving approach that looks at a system as a whole. Making sense of the complexity in our world is not an easy task, but mastering the principles of systems thinking can bring us one step closer to achieving sustainable goals. Rather than isolating parts of a system (like linear thinking does), systems thinking is the ability to understand systems as a whole and the dependent relationships. With systems thinking, we have a much better chance to find the solutions which fit.

Climate Anxiety First Aid Kit: Do Not Let Climate Panic Become The Norm

Climate anxiety is a relatively new phenomenon. It occurs when people increasingly see, hear or read bad news about environmental impacts in connection with the climate crisis. Consequently, people are scared of the consequences that make the future look grim. Negative emotions like distress, anger and hopelessness contribute to a spiral of worries that might have a bigger impact on their life than the effects of the climate crisis. Luckily, there are different and simple ways to deal with climate anxiety. No one has to suffer in silence, but it means taking action and taking matters into our hands.

Sustainability Mindset – A Mindset For A Better World

A Sustainability Mindset helps us to understand complex systems better. Through awareness about everything that’s going wrong, we create the ability to step one step back and reflect on the situation. A Sustainability mindset helps us to effectively analyse complex challenges and generate appropriate solutions. Embracing Sustainability has never been easier by applying the 12 principles of a Sustainability mindset. We don’t always need cutting-edge technology. Sometimes real change comes from within us; to create the impact we want to see in our world. Sustainability is not difficult nor hard, it’s everything good we want to create. For us, for others, for the planet.

From A Carbon Tunnel Vision To A Holistic Collaboration Approach

Sustainable development has a very carbon-heavy taste to it. It has already been recognised that we need to move beyond the carbon-only approaches; to achieve effective, sustainable outcomes. What we experience globally is a Carbon Tunnel Vision. It’s a clever play on words to highlight our selective attention on mostly Net-Zero Goals. The Carbon Tunnel Vision framework aims to open our eyes to other human and natural crises. Global warming is only one part of the interconnected crises. Let’s not get trapped and miss our chances to fight our challenges effectively. I want to show you how easy this can be by taking a more holistic and collaborative approach.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This